All videos

Pay For More iCloud Storage Vs. External Hard Drive For iPhone?

Download the full PDF guide

Free. Enter your email and the PDF downloads right away. You also join my weekly email newsletter. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy

An external hard drive costs less over time. iCloud costs more, but it backs up your iPhone without you doing anything. These are the pros and cons of each, so you can pick.

Keep photos out of iCloud

A viewer asked how to move every photo and album off the iPhone, because they did not want personal things in iCloud. That got me thinking about the trade. You can keep everything on your iPhone and back it up to iCloud, or you can copy it to an external drive.

A hard drive costs less

A drive is a one-time cost. When I recorded this, a 2 terabyte external hard drive was $130 on Amazon. Almost nobody has that much on a phone, so one drive covers nearly everyone.

  1. Open Amazon and search for an external hard drive. Compare the price with the amount of storage you get.
  • Tap
  • Amazon

My earlier video shows how to copy your photos and videos from the iPhone to the drive.

How hard drives fail you

A drive has two weak points. It can fail, and it only works if you remember to use it.

  1. Open Safari and search for how often external hard drives fail. The answer I found was between 1.2 and 1.4 percent a year.
  • Tap
  • Safari

You can also lose the drive, or a flood or fire at home can destroy it. I think the bigger risk is more hidden. A drive backup is manual. You plug the drive into your iPhone, copy the new photos and videos over, and put the drive somewhere safe. Every time you skip that, your newest photos have no backup.

How safe iCloud is

iCloud costs more, so I looked up whether it has been hacked. The answer I found was that single iCloud accounts have been broken into, but nobody has gotten into Apple’s iCloud servers and stolen what is stored there. That was true as of 2026.

A drive at home is different. If someone breaks in and takes it, they can open everything on it, unless you encrypted the drive.

What iCloud storage costs

Your iPhone shows how much iCloud storage you pay for, how much is used, and what a bigger plan costs.

  1. Open Settings.
  2. Tap [Your name] at the top.
  3. Tap iCloud, about halfway down. The top of the screen shows how much iCloud storage you pay for and how much you have used.
  4. Tap Storage at the top.
  5. Tap Change Storage Plan.
  6. Tap iCloud+. If you pay for Apple One, tap that row instead.
  7. Tap See All Plans. Every plan is listed with its price.
  • Tap
  • Settings
  • [Your name]
  • iCloud
  • Storage
  • Change Storage Plan
  • iCloud+
  • See All Plans

The 50 gigabyte plan is about $1 a month. The 2 terabyte plan, the same size as that hard drive, is $9.99 a month. That is about $120 a year. So the hard drive pays for itself in about one year. After that, iCloud is the more expensive choice.

What iCloud backs up

iCloud does more than hold photos. It saves what is in your apps too, and it does that on its own. If your iPhone is lost or stolen, you can put everything back on a new iPhone.

  1. Tap the X to close the list of plans. Then tap the back arrow three times to return to the iCloud screen.
  2. Next to Saved to iCloud, tap See All. Each app that is turned on here is saved in iCloud.
  • Tap
  • See All

On my iPhone that list has Photos, iCloud Drive, iCloud Mail, Passwords, Notes, Messages, Health and Contacts. iCloud Drive holds the files and documents from my iPhone and my Mac.

Now picture the same loss with only a hard drive. If your last copy to the drive was weeks or months ago, everything since then was only on the iPhone. That part is gone.

Which one is right for you

I use iCloud. I like that it is convenient and that everything is backed up if something happens. If you want to save money and do it yourself, an external hard drive is a great option too.

You can also do both. Pay for a small iCloud plan, and copy photos and videos to a drive on a regular schedule. Deleting them from your iPhone afterward frees up space, but read the warning below first.

Watch this on YouTube and ask your question in the comments.

Free iPhone guide

Get my 20 iPhone Settings To Fix Today

  • Free now Join the free waitlist and the guide comes by email right away. After that, I send one useful iPhone tip about once a week.
  • Paid, later iPhone 101 is my full video course. It will cost under $100, one payment, and opens early 2027. The waitlist hears first.

unsubscribe link in every email